26 Sep 11
Originally posted by nimzo5is that good or bad?
I think WW is talking about non Maroczy Bind Dragon positions.
some stats on Robbies posted pawn structure from my database-
White won 30517 games, drew 20709, lost 21391
So 42%,29%, 29% for the percentile inclined.
Needless to say this is not endgame stats just an overview.
26 Sep 11
Originally posted by robbie carrobieBetter for white than black. However, I suspect that a lot of that is Sicilian players expecting a proper knife edge Sicilian and finding they have wandered into the English by mistake. I'd be happy as black in that position, but I wouldn't have wasted time playing cxd4. Let white work out what to do with his d-pawn.
is that good or bad?
26 Sep 11
1 edit
Originally posted by Diophantusnow we are getting to the grit of the matter. What has white to worry about his d pawn
Better for white than black. However, I suspect that a lot of that is Sicilian players expecting a proper knife edge Sicilian and finding they have wandered into the English by mistake. I'd be happy as black in that position, but I wouldn't have wasted time playing cxd4. Let white work out what to do with his d-pawn.
for, its going to d4 whether black likes it or not, it supported by the queen, nothing can
stop it, the whole reason for black playing ...c5 is to take the sting out of it, he cannot
prevent it. We are invincible!
26 Sep 11
Originally posted by robbie carrobieBut then what do you do with the d-pawn once it reaches d4? If I am not going to oblige with cxd4 what do you do with the pawn? Some play d5, lovely, that leaves a weakness behind it. Some play dxc5 and get all confused when black plays Bxc3 (if the knight has gone to c3) or Qa5+ (if the knight isn't on c3). Leaving the pawn on d4 just creates a target for g7-bishop, c6 knight and any bits that black wants to point that way. Either way, it is now white who isn't getting quite what he expected.
now we are getting to the grit of the matter. What has white to worry about his d pawn
for, its going to d4 whether black likes it or not, it supported by the queen, nothing can
stop it, the whole reason for black playing ...c5 is to take the sting out of it, he cannot
prevent it. We are invincible!
26 Sep 11
Originally posted by Diophantusyou are practically forced to take the d pawn after 1.e4 c5, 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.d4, you have practically no other good moves, 3...Nf6 fails to e5, 3...d6 or 3...e6 or 3...g6 simply allows c4. Its not really a target, white wants black to take the d pawn.
But then what do you do with the d-pawn once it reaches d4? If I am not going to oblige with cxd4 what do you do with the pawn? Some play d5, lovely, that leaves a weakness behind it. Some play dxc5 and get all confused when black plays Bxc3 (if the knight has gone to c3) or Qa5+ (if the knight isn't on c3). Leaving the pawn on d4 just creates a target fo ...[text shortened]... wants to point that way. Either way, it is now white who isn't getting quite what he expected.
26 Sep 11
Originally posted by robbie carrobieWhite may want black to take the d-pawn, but he is not intending to sacrifice it. He wants to get his pawn back. That is what makes it a target, we build up sufficient force to grab it and keep it. c4 is not a worry, in the position you posted and the position for which statistics were given, c4 has already happened, as have g6 and d6. Worse still, you have that pawn on f3 for some reason. Is that there to annoy your king's knight?
you are practically forced to take the d pawn after 1.e4 c5, 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.d4, you have practically no other good moves, 3...Nf6 fails to e5, 3...d6 or 3...e6 or 3...g6 simply allows c4. Its not really a target, white wants black to take the d pawn.
I wouldn't be playing your move order though. I reach a similar position by 1. e4 (or d4) g6 2. d4 (or e4) Bg7 3. Nc3 (or Nf3 or c4 or...) c5. Are you going to leave that pawn on d4 in the hope I will take it?
26 Sep 11
1 edit
Originally posted by Diophantusbut this is a different monster altogether, grab it an keep it, muhaha, my man, you'll be
White may want black to take the d-pawn, but he is not intending to sacrifice it. He wants to get his pawn back. That is what makes it a target, we build up sufficient force to grab it and keep it. c4 is not a worry, in the position you posted and the position for which statistics were given, c4 has already happened, as have g6 and d6. Worse still, you ha c3 (or Nf3 or c4 or...) c5. Are you going to leave that pawn on d4 in the hope I will take it?
roasty toasty before that happens! the pawn on f3 was there because the position
demanded it, we cannot apply the same criteria to a completely different system, the e
pawn was attacked by the Kings knight, anyway, now that i have busted the Dragon
and the Najdorf, will i find a bust to your modern/pirc? using my beloved bind ? after
my last disaster playing you, it will be my pleasure!
26 Sep 11
Originally posted by robbie carrobieIs that a request for another trouncing? If so, I'll send a game over.
but this is a different monster altogether, grab it an keep it, muhaha, my man, you'll be
roasty toasty before that happens! the pawn on f3 was there because the position
demanded it, we cannot apply the same criteria to a completely different system, the e
pawn was attacked by the Kings knight, anyway, now that i have busted the Dragon
and ...[text shortened]... /pirc? using my beloved bind ? after
my last disaster playing you, it will be my pleasure!
26 Sep 11
1 edit
Originally posted by Diophantusmy man, its not the result , but the learning experience
Is that a request for another trouncing? If so, I'll send a game over.
(yeah right, we play to win the game!) 😛
soon as i am ready youll be smokin like a kipper in the fires of hell! challenge me, put a large time bank on it (14days), so i can do my researches!