@ Robbie & Galveston: Merry Christmas

Originally posted by FMF
Well post-early Christians and modern Christians commemorate the birth of Christ. What "lie" is it you reckon they are telling?

I think I've clearly explained this already. I can see this as usual is going to be a dead end with your never ending questions that you never accept any explinations for or really never care to learn.
Good night..........

Originally posted by galveston75
Yep. I still don't know why I answer his post. I must need help...Lol

sumydid did not seem interested in the discussion you and I are having. He seemed more fixated on me.

Originally posted by galveston75
I think I've clearly explained this already. I can see this as usual is going to be a dead end with your never ending questions that you never accept any explinations for or really never care to learn.
Good night..........

You have claimed that Christians were telling "lies". But you have not explained what "lies" you reckon they are telling.

Originally posted by galveston75
Why does that matter to you? What are you after as this seems to be getting weird?

Why can't you just answer the question I've repeatedly put to you with a yes or a no?

I shall have to assume it is because you do enjoy some festive social activity and that in fact Christmas is not just any other day in your household; and that you simply don't want to admit it.

Originally posted by divegeester
Why can't you just answer the question I've repeatedly put to you with a yes or a no?

I shall have to assume it is because you do enjoy some festive social activity and that in fact Christmas is not just any other day in your household; and that you simply don't want to admit it.

Reverse the roles.

Originally posted by Grampy Bobby
Reverse the roles.

And?

Originally posted by divegeester
Why can't you just answer the question I've repeatedly put to you with a yes or a no?

I shall have to assume it is because you do enjoy some festive social activity and that in fact Christmas is not just any other day in your household; and that you simply don't want to admit it.

Lol. Do you understand english? I have answered you. Perhaps your glasses are dirty?

Originally posted by galveston75
Lol. Do you understand english? I have answered you. Perhaps your glasses are dirty?

You haven't answered me. You have not explained what "lies" you reckon all Christians who commemorate Jesus' birth are telling.

Originally posted by divegeester

And?

... see yourself as others see you.

“O, wad some Power the giftie gie us
To see oursels as others see us!
It wad frae monie a blunder free us,
An' foolish notion.” (Robert Burns)
.

Originally posted by FMF
You haven't answered me. You have not explained what "lies" you reckon all Christians who commemorate Jesus' birth are telling.

Uh yes I did. Your powers of perception are not working.

Originally posted by galveston75
Uh yes I did. Your powers of perception are not working.

You have dodged this specific question repeatedly and now you suddenly say you've answered it. You do this all the time.

Can you list these "lies" that Christians who commemorate Jesus' birth are telling?

Just run through them here in brief. Lie #1, Lie #2, etc.

Originally posted by galveston75
Lol. Do you understand english? I have answered you. Perhaps your glasses are dirty?

No you haven't; and you know you haven't.

I asked you if you did anything out of the ordinary in terms of social gathering, gift giving or dining with friends or family during the festive period?

Either you did, or you didn't.

Originally posted by divegeester
No you haven't; and you know you haven't.

I asked you if you did anything out of the ordinary in terms of social gathering, gift giving or dining with friends or family during the festive period?

Either you did, or you didn't.

Actually it's just none of your business.....

Originally posted by galveston75
Actually it's just none of your business.....

So in saying that, you admit that you hadn't answered the question!

I wonder why...



Edit: Grampy Bobby, perhaps now you can see why some of us in this forum have to pin these JWs down to specific answers or you get repeated hemming and hawing.

Originally posted by Grampy Bobby
... see yourself as others see you.

I am what I am here Grampy Bobby; consistent, straightforward and as honest as I can be.

Can you say the same?