Y Chromosome

Originally posted by chaney3
Then I question your Christianity.

So what?

Originally posted by chaney3
Miracles likely still must maintain physical law.

No they don't, by their very definition.

Originally posted by chaney3
Meaning, Jesus must have the Y chromosome. You are trying to input a miracle that NT writers were not aware of.

You honestly think that people 2,000 years ago were so primitive that they hadn't figured out that conception was the result of men and women having sex and that a "virgin birth" was therefore a miracle?

Originally posted by chaney3
Meaning......WE NOW view the chromosome issue as a possible issue, which they didn't know.

Why did people have to know "the chromosome issue" in order to know that sexual intercourse was necessary in order to conceive children?

Originally posted by FMF
Why did people have to know "the chromosome issue" in order to know that sexual intercourse was necessary in order to conceive children?

Because.....if one is not aware of the Y chromosome issue, then one could conceive the notion of immaculate conception.

Are you getting it?

Originally posted by chaney3
Because.....if one is not aware of the Y chromosome issue, then one could conceive the notion of immaculate conception.

Are you getting it?

You are ignoring what I am saying. Conception through sexual intercourse was understood. Conception without sexual intercourse would have been seen as impossible and therefore, if it occurred, it would be seen as a miracle. Knowledge of the biology chromosomes was not necessary or relevant.

Originally posted by FMF
You are ignoring what I am saying. Conception through sexual intercourse was understood. Conception without sexual intercourse would have been seen as impossible and therefore, if it occurred, it would be seen as a miracle. Knowledge of the biology chromosomes was not necessary or relevant.

Explain where the Y chromosome came from.

According to your posts, God provided it. Right?

Originally posted by chaney3
Explain where the Y chromosome came from.

According to your posts, God provided it. Right?

Personally, I assume it was provided by Joseph.

Christians who believe in the "virgin birth", on the other hand, believe that Jesus was conceived by Mary through the agency of the Holy Spirit and that it was therefore a miracle.

Originally posted by FMF
Personally, I assume it was provided by Joseph.

Christians who believe in the "virgin birth", on the other hand, believe that Jesus was conceived by Mary through the agency of the Holy Spirit and that it was therefore a miracle.

So......the Holy Spirit provided the Y chromosome?

Tell your pal Dive that Christianity needs more evidence before one commits their soul to it.

Originally posted by chaney3
Tell your pal Dive that Christianity needs more evidence before one commits their soul to it.

Is this what you've been itching to say all along?

Originally posted by chaney3
So......the Holy Spirit provided the Y chromosome?

If it's true, and this is indeed what happened, then it must have been a miracle, because under the natural and scientific laws that govern our lives, the Y chromosome needed to have come from a human male.

Originally posted by FMF
Is this what you've been itching to say all along?

Absolutely not.

I will hear his BS before I comment.

chaney3: Tell your pal Dive that Christianity needs more evidence before one commits their soul to it.

FMF: Is this what you've been itching to say all along?

Originally posted by chaney3
Absolutely not.

So it was a spontaneous 'discussion point'?

Originally posted by chaney3
I will hear his BS before I comment.

Do you think that the concept of Jesus' birth being the result of a miracle is "BS"?

Originally posted by FMF
Do you think that the concept of Jesus' birth being the result of a miracle is "BS"?

You do.