Go back
Is trans trendy now?

Is trans trendy now?

General

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120562
Clock
15 Jul 23

@kilroy70 said

You seem to have a fair amount of natural intelligence, so what's the problem?
The only problem is that I’m on your case Lemon Lad.

K
within reason

Joined
28 Nov 21
Moves
4443
Clock
15 Jul 23

@ghost-of-a-duke said
As a reasonably intelligent fellow, I think a person's sexuality shouldn't be a factor in whether or not a baker decides to sell them a cake.

That's my view, as a reasonably intelligent fellow.
So why was it a factor for the gay couple?
There are at least half a dozen other bakeries that would have gladly filled their order. So why did they go to the one bakery they knew was not sympathetic to their lifestyle? Out of all the bakeries they could have gone to, why that one?
It doesn't take an Adrian Monk to solve this mystery. All it takes is a scant teaspoon of common sense.

Earl of Trumps
Pawn Whisperer

My Kingdom fora Pawn

Joined
09 Jan 19
Moves
20419
Clock
16 Jul 23

@FMF said - do you support the hundreds of laws that have been passed across numerous conservative states
in recent years that seek to discriminate against, harass and demonize trans people

-----------------------------------------------

Well, obviously, I would have to judge each law on an individual basis, but the way you make them all sound,
I doubt I can support such laws. You may ask about any specific law now, if you like.

Also, I am a Libertarian and I believe in freedom. And what that means here is that a person can do
whatever they want on their own property. My stance there usually gets the socialists excitedly against 🙂

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
16 Jul 23
1 edit

@earl-of-trumps said
Well, obviously, I would have to judge each law on an individual basis, but the way you make them all sound,
I doubt I can support such laws. You may ask about any specific law now, if you like.

Also, I am a Libertarian and I believe in freedom. And what that means here is that a person can do
whatever they want on their own property. My stance there usually gets the socialists excitedly against 🙂
If what you claim about yourself is true, then why on page 1 did you disingenuously pretend that anyone is asking you to go down on "bended knee, showering the trans with kissy-faces and glowing accolades"?

Your sneering hyperbole is a rhetorical gimmick that sounds little different to the talking points of people in your country who appear to hate trans people so much that they are passing laws to proactively discriminate against them.

Ghost of a Duke

Joined
14 Mar 15
Moves
29597
Clock
16 Jul 23

@kilroy70 said
So why was it a factor for the gay couple?
There are at least half a dozen other bakeries that would have gladly filled their order. So why did they go to the one bakery they knew was not sympathetic to their lifestyle? Out of all the bakeries they could have gone to, why that one?
It doesn't take an Adrian Monk to solve this mystery. All it takes is a scant teaspoon of common sense.
A scant teaspoon of common sense would lead a chap to atheism and away from such discriminatory behaviour.

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120562
Clock
16 Jul 23

@kilroy70 said
So why was it a factor for the gay couple?
There are at least half a dozen other bakeries that would have gladly filled their order. So why did they go to the one bakery they knew was not sympathetic to their lifestyle? Out of all the bakeries they could have gone to, why that one?
It doesn't take an Adrian Monk to solve this mystery. All it takes is a scant teaspoon of common sense.
Can you name a few of “the hundreds of laws that have been passed across numerous liberal states in recent years that seek to discriminate against, harass and demonize christians and republicans” ???

Shallow Blue

Joined
18 Jan 07
Moves
12477
Clock
16 Jul 23

@divegeester said
Surely it’s illegal to discriminate in your ridiculous country?
No. No, it evidently isn't.

K
within reason

Joined
28 Nov 21
Moves
4443
Clock
16 Jul 23
1 edit

@ghost-of-a-duke said
A scant teaspoon of common sense would lead a chap to atheism and away from such discriminatory behaviour.
Discrimination based on what, your own firmly established atheism?

Using your logic, if a white couple set out to disrupt a company run by blacks, you could accuse that company of discriminatory behavior (based on race). Is that really the sort of pandoras box you want to see opened, not just in the US or UK but anywhere?

I know, I know, a lot of questions (and question marks) here. But they are mostly rhetorical, because I find it difficult to believe you are okay with predatory behavior in some instances but not in others.

K
within reason

Joined
28 Nov 21
Moves
4443
Clock
16 Jul 23
1 edit

@divegeester said
Can you name a few of “the hundreds of laws that have been passed across numerous liberal states in recent years that seek to discriminate against, harass and demonize christians and republicans” ???
That was a response to FMF. He said:

"do you support the hundreds of laws that have been passed across numerous conservative states in recent years that seek to discriminate against, harass and demonize trans people?"

I'm still waiting for him to name a few of the hundreds of laws that have been passed across numerous conservative states in recent years that seek to discriminate against, harass and demonize trans people.

Ghost of a Duke

Joined
14 Mar 15
Moves
29597
Clock
16 Jul 23

@kilroy70 said
Discrimination based on what, your own firmly established atheism?

Using your logic, if a white couple set out to disrupt a company run by blacks, you could accuse that company of discriminatory behavior (based on race). Is that really the sort of pandoras box you want to see opened, not just in the US or UK but anywhere and everywhere?

I know, I know, a lot of questio ...[text shortened]... nd it difficult to believe you are okay with predatory behavior in some instances but not in others.
There is nothing predatory in asking a bakery to make a wedding cake, nor is it the customer's job to research the religious values of the baker. And you are presuming the couple sought out a Christian baker to cause an issue, rather than the far more likely scenario of a Christian baker allowing their faith to discriminate against a gay customer who rightly felt aggrieved by being declined custom as a result of their sexuality.

When the gay couple were looking for a wedding cake, should they have Googled 'non-Christian bakeries?' And would every Christian baker acted in such a fashion? I doubt it.

K
within reason

Joined
28 Nov 21
Moves
4443
Clock
16 Jul 23

@ghost-of-a-duke said
There is nothing predatory in asking a bakery to make a wedding cake, nor is it the customer's job to research the religious values of the baker. And you are presuming the couple sought out a Christian baker to cause an issue, rather than the far more likely scenario of a Christian baker allowing their faith to discriminate against a gay customer who rightly felt aggr ...[text shortened]... ogled 'non-Christian bakeries?' And would every Christian baker acted in such a fashion? I doubt it.
I'm not presuming anything. It was confirmed by an acquaintance of the couple who came forward and said they intentionally targeted the Christian business. He was personally offended by their actions, and was worried over how public perception of this event might impact the gay community.

Ghost of a Duke

Joined
14 Mar 15
Moves
29597
Clock
16 Jul 23

@kilroy70 said
I'm not presuming anything. It was confirmed by an acquaintance of the couple who came forward and said they intentionally targeted the Christian business. He was personally offended by their actions, and was worried over how public perception of this event might impact the gay community.
Have you provided a link somewhere to this example you have given?

It rather sounds like you are making it up as you go along.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
16 Jul 23
1 edit

@kilroy70 said
And what of yourself? Do you support the hundreds of laws that have been passed across numerous liberal states in recent years that seek to discriminate against, harass and demonize christians and republicans?
I am not aware of any.

K
within reason

Joined
28 Nov 21
Moves
4443
Clock
16 Jul 23
1 edit

@ghost-of-a-duke said
Have you provided a link somewhere to this example you have given?

It rather sounds like you are making it up as you go along.
I'm not surprised you would presume I was making this up.
What the acquaintance said barely showed up in a local news source, and there was never any mention of it in any of the national news outlets (conservative or left wing). I most likely saw it in one of the many local neighborhood newspapers... which btw are predominantly left wing papers.

Regardless, the acquaintance didn't say anything many of us who actually live here didn't already know.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
16 Jul 23

@kilroy70 said
And what of yourself? Do you support the hundreds of laws that have been passed across numerous liberal states in recent years that seek to discriminate against, harass and demonize christians and republicans?
Do you have any online resources listing these "hundreds of laws"?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.