Go back
New Order or Joy Division?

New Order or Joy Division?

General

A

Joined
28 Nov 06
Moves
8629
Clock
10 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

I actually have a hip hop CD, mixed by this guy Mike Relm, and the last like 4 to 6 records he plays are Joy Division records.

e

Joined
17 Mar 04
Moves
82844
Clock
11 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Joy Division by a country mile.

When I played in Mere Mortals, we did all original songs expect for two covers, one by Echo & The Bunnymen, the other, Joy Division's "Interzone" which I sang lead on.

d

Joined
19 Mar 05
Moves
11878
Clock
11 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by eagles54
Joy Division by a country mile.

When I played in Mere Mortals, we did all original songs expect for two covers, one by Echo & The Bunnymen, the other, Joy Division's "Interzone" which I sang lead on.
I love Echo and the Bunnymen!

P
Upward Spiral

Halfway

Joined
02 Aug 04
Moves
8702
Clock
11 May 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by darvlay
Which do you prefer and why?
Straciatella.
Edit - 'Cause it taste' goooood.

JJ

Joined
28 Feb 07
Moves
1295
Clock
11 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by demonseed
I love Echo and the Bunnymen!
I love The Cure.... Robert Smith is a genius !!!!

u
The So Fist

Voice of Reason

Joined
28 Mar 06
Moves
9908
Clock
11 May 07
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Come on now you New Order bashers...

While Joy Division is no doubt a great band and influenced tonnes of bands that followed, New Order also did the same for the whole Electronica scene that peaked in the early 90's (until it was killed by Euro-Trash and highschool idiots driving down the street with the bass cranked up so loud their whole car rattled.)

New Order (with a nod to Kraftwerk..check out "She's a Model"...) paved the evolutionary road for Nine Inch Nails, Chemical Brothers, Prodigy, Lords of Acid, Thrill Kill Kult and a whole host of spin off genres that would meld electronica beats with heavy Industrial sounds including KMFDM. For those that remember, the Techno-Industrial scene in early 90's was just as good as the whole Seattle sound explosion with Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden and eventually Smashing Pumpkins. Music had it's second coming in 1990-1994.

Sadly, this all died and was replaced with Hip Hop after the Electronica and Industrial scene died and the younger crowd became more interested in image than substance and we've been stuck with 10 years of garbage on the airwaves and everyone doing their best Bower Bird impressions. (Check out David Attenborough's "The Life Of Birds" PBS tv show about Bower Birds and you'll know what I mean)


Watch the movie 24 Hour Party People for a good recap that includes Joy Division and New Order and how the scene started.


But if you can't even get into songs like Blue Monday, Confusion, Thieves like Us, and Bizzare Love Triangle, then wow do you ever have a limited musical palette.

Amaurote
No Name Maddox

County Doledrum

Joined
04 Feb 05
Moves
16156
Clock
13 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by uzless
Come on now you New Order bashers...

While Joy Division is no doubt a great band and influenced tonnes of bands that followed, New Order also did the same for the whole Electronica scene that peaked in the early 90's
It's difficult to separate, really - Joy Division had already signalled that they would go down the Electronica route, and songs like "Something Must Break", "Isolation" and "She's Lost Control" show that they were already handling it extremely well. I think the main difference for me is that while Bernard Sumner was a great musician, his lyrics often left a great deal to be desired.

S

Joined
14 Jul 06
Moves
20541
Clock
13 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by darvlay
New Order or Joy Division?
The Stone Roses

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.