Atheist Circular Reasoning

Originally posted by @stellspalfie
Two climate scientists walk into a bar, both experts in their field. They both examine the evidence and draw different conclusions as to the cause of climate change Should they hand the evidence over to an attorney to find the correct answer.

No, but you’re talking in your hypothetical of evidence that requires specialized knowledge to properly review.

Not the same as evidence for Jesus Christ’s Resurrection.

Originally posted by @wolfgang59
Three experts?
Experts in what?

Experts in the evaluation of evidence. If you read the article, you would know that.

Would you like a link to the article about the three experts? Didn’t think so.

Originally posted by @romans1009
Experts in the evaluation of evidence.

What?
They were detectives?
Forensic scientists?

Originally posted by @wolfgang59
What?
They were detectives?
Forensic scientists?

By all accounts their evidence is overwhelming.

Originally posted by @wolfgang59
What?
They were detectives?
Forensic scientists?

Feel free to educate yourself...

https://www.allaboutthejourney.org/the-case-for-christ.htm

Originally posted by @romans1009
Feel free to educate yourself...

https://www.allaboutthejourney.org/the-case-for-christ.htm

Feel free to educate yourself.

https://www.amazon.com/Science-Childrens-Encyclopedia-DK/dp/1409347923




15 all

Originally posted by @wolfgang59
Feel free to educate yourself.

https://www.amazon.com/Science-Childrens-Encyclopedia-DK/dp/1409347923




15 all

So did you check out the article you seemed interested in?

Originally posted by @romans1009
So did you check out the article you seemed interested in?

I check out lots of articles I'm interested in.

Originally posted by @wolfgang59
I check out lots of articles I'm interested in.

I mean the article about the three experts in reviewing evidence.

Originally posted by @romans1009
I mean the article about the three experts in reviewing evidence.

I thought you had read it.

Originally posted by @romans1009
No, but you’re talking in your hypothetical of evidence that requires specialized knowledge to properly review.

Not the same as evidence for Jesus Christ’s Resurrection.

What type of evidence is there for the resurrection

Originally posted by @stellspalfie
What type of evidence is there for the resurrection

Get ready sir to be overwhelmed....

Originally posted by @romans1009
What amazes me about atheists is how much time they spend advancing essentially an anti position.

If you don’t believe something, fine. Why waste time trying to convince others not to believe? Where is the satisfaction in that?

I also find amazing that atheists will say they think it’s great someone finds comfort and support in believing in God, wh ...[text shortened]... e simultaneously trying to take that away.

Bizarre people. Nuttier than a bowl of mixed nuts.

Yeah, your god has produced such incredible results in the last 2000 years eh. This allegedly loving god not doing anything about the crusades, witch hunting, instead actively suppressing any independent thinking that took over a thousand years to overcome and actually make a tech savvy civilization we have now where WE HUMANS have brought down the horrific infant mortality rate of 2000 years ago. Wonder why your god didn't instruct us better on THAT one back in the day? That and a thousand other things HUMANS did for themselves in spite of the suppression of early religions and even religions of today.

Yessir, great record you so-called god has.

I have always said I want freedom FROM religion not freedom OF religion.

Modern organized religions are the scourge of mankind and no doubt about that.

Funny how the leaders of present day organized religions ALWAYS have the best of everything, best housing, food, transport, money.

I'm SURE your god wanted that.

I guess it would have been impossible for every member of the human race to have been told by your god 'look, this is how it is', etc., rather than the utter crap going on now where a dude goes, 'I am the voice of god, trust me' and we suckers fall for it hook line and sinker yet not a WORD from your so-called god.

Funny how that works.

But of COURSE that makes ME a nutter since all my arguments are CLEARLY circular.

Originally posted by @sonhouse
Yeah, your god has produced such incredible results in the last 2000 years eh. This allegedly loving god not doing anything about the crusades, witch hunting, instead actively suppressing any independent thinking that took over a thousand years to overcome and actually make a tech savvy civilization we have now where WE HUMANS have brought down the horrifi ...[text shortened]... that works.

But of COURSE that makes ME a nutter since all my arguments are CLEARLY circular.

I didn’t read your whole post because it seemed like a rant, but in the parts I read, you’re blaming God for human decisions and human behavior.

Apparently you want humans to have free will but want to blame God for everything they do with it. And I suspect if humans do something good, why that’s in spite of God!

Originally posted by @stellspalfie
What type of evidence is there for the resurrection

I’ll be happy to provide a link to an article that gives a 30,000-foot view of *some* of the evidence. Let me know if you want me to.