Go back
Has religion served its purpose?

Has religion served its purpose?

Spirituality

diver

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
121318
Clock
01 Jan 22

@josephw said
No. It is pure logic.

"Religious beliefs" notwithstanding.
No, it’s you trying to disingenuously distance yourself from your religion in some sort of vainglorious effort to reinvent your stance here such that you don’t have to defend it, don’t have to deny it and more importantly, you don’t have to discuss your personal support of the worst bits of it.

diver

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
121318
Clock
01 Jan 22

@josephw said
That's right. My "religion" is Christianity.
Well, that was hard work.

Got there in the end though.

diver

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
121318
Clock
01 Jan 22

@josephw said
That's right. My "religion" is Christianity.
Then why did you claim this above…?

“I am not "religious", nor are my "claims" regarding the supernatural derived from any "religious beliefs".”

diver

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
121318
Clock
01 Jan 22

@josephw said
God doesn't "require", He commands us to love Him.
So your God’s commandments don’t “require” you to obey them?

diver

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
121318
Clock
01 Jan 22
1 edit

@josephw I might read the rest your incoherent ramblings later, there are other posters, such as chaney3, who are more interesting.

KellyJay
Walk your Faith

USA

Joined
24 May 04
Moves
162265
Clock
01 Jan 22
Vote Up
Vote Down

@fmf said
The OP is not specifically about your God figure, it should perhaps be noted. It's about religions and societies in general.
In general, shouldn't it take in all opinions, but I'll step out if you are against how I stepped in.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
01 Jan 22

@kellyjay said
In general, shouldn't it take in all opinions, but I'll step out if you are against how I stepped in.
If you had to choose between living in one of three southeast Asian countries, a Muslim majority one (but not an Islamic state), a majority Buddhist [i.e. non- theist] country, or a majority atheist country, where most democraphic data were more or less similar in all three countries, which one would you imagine choosing?

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
01 Jan 22

@kellyjay said
In general, shouldn't it take in all opinions, but I'll step out if you are against how I stepped in.
To my way of thinking, you'd grabbed the wrong end of this thread's stick and were perhaps all set to simply resume making assertions about your own religion which you can and are doing elsewhere. Sorry if I seemed abrupt.

a
Not actually a cat

The Flat Earth

Joined
09 Apr 10
Moves
14988
Clock
01 Jan 22
Vote Up
Vote Down

@fmf said
"Religion has served its purpose of uniting people, setting up structures in society, developing trust and cooperation."

~ Syed Saleem Ali

"What we need now are morality and spirituality. Morality is about reducing suffering in the world. And spirituality is about questioning and looking for answers. Religions provide us just with answers and no scope of questions.”

~ Y ...[text shortened]... uniting people, supporting structures in society, and developing trust and cooperation.

Thoughts?
I think that like most human institutions, religion can be a double-edged sword, although I feel that in general, religions are mostly beneficial and that human society would not benefit by their passing.

R
Standard memberRemoved

Joined
25 Nov 21
Moves
1990
Clock
01 Jan 22

@fmf said
"Religion has served its purpose of uniting people, setting up structures in society, developing trust and cooperation."

~ Syed Saleem Ali

"What we need now are morality and spirituality. Morality is about reducing suffering in the world. And spirituality is about questioning and looking for answers. Religions provide us just with answers and no scope of questions.”

~ Y ...[text shortened]... uniting people, supporting structures in society, and developing trust and cooperation.

Thoughts?
I think we’ve seen what happens when atheists are in charge of countries. They wind up killing millions of their own countrymen.

In fact, in the 20th century alone, atheists running communist governments are estimated to have murdered 250 million people.

That’s what happens when atheists have absolute power and think they have no accountability and that human beings are animals. Murder becomes an acceptable response to dissent.

Rajk999
Kali

PenTesting

Joined
04 Apr 04
Moves
261063
Clock
01 Jan 22

@josephw said
That's right. My "religion" is Christianity.

Remember when Jesus said, while on the cross, after the three hours of darkness?

Jesus said "it is finished".

My "religion" is based on that. I did nothing.

My "relationship" with the living God is based on what Jesus did on the cross to secure my eternal destination without any help from me.

"Religion" is the obs ...[text shortened]... said "it is finished".

That's the thing you don't get in spite of everything you think you know.
This is the nonsense the churches preach and fool lazy people who just want to do nothing. When Jesus said it is finished he meant his work is finished and this is clearly stated in other parts of the gospels. Jesus did not mean your work is finished. If you read beyond that sentence you would see that you have work to do, otherwise there is no inheritance in the Kingdom of God. Your entire doctrine of doing nothing, or thinking mans efforts can accomplish nothing or is worthless, runs contrary to all the teachings of the bible. Your doctrine results in dead faith and it is only a living faith that can lead to eternal life.

Ghost of a Duke

Joined
14 Mar 15
Moves
29756
Clock
01 Jan 22
Vote Up
Vote Down

@rajk999 said
This is the nonsense the churches preach and fool lazy people who just want to do nothing. When Jesus said it is finished he meant his work is finished and this is clearly stated in other parts of the gospels. Jesus did not mean your work is finished. If you read beyond that sentence you would see that you have work to do, otherwise there is no inheritance in the Kingdom of ...[text shortened]... e. Your doctrine results in dead faith and it is only a living faith that can lead to eternal life.
Some Christians not only want God to wipe away their sins but also to do their praying for them. Anything to resolve themselves of any responsibility or effort.

Rajk999
Kali

PenTesting

Joined
04 Apr 04
Moves
261063
Clock
01 Jan 22

@ghost-of-a-duke said
Some Christians not only want God to wipe away their sins but also to do their praying for them. Anything to resolve themselves of any responsibility or effort.
They move further and further away from Christ with every passing decade

Rajk999
Kali

PenTesting

Joined
04 Apr 04
Moves
261063
Clock
01 Jan 22
Vote Up
Vote Down

@avalanchethecat said
I think that like most human institutions, religion can be a double-edged sword, although I feel that in general, religions are mostly beneficial and that human society would not benefit by their passing.
From the teachings of Christ one can deduce that the best thing for mankind is to remove religion and each and every individual be their brothers keeper, ie live charitable lifestyle. You do not need organised religion to do that.

R
Standard memberRemoved

Joined
25 Nov 21
Moves
1990
Clock
01 Jan 22

@ghost-of-a-duke said
Some Christians not only want God to wipe away their sins but also to do their praying for them. Anything to resolve themselves of any responsibility or effort.
God can and does do both.

But the Apostle Paul (and I as well) believe in praying in the Spirit *and* praying with understanding,

Have you ever prayed?

And you’re falling into the same trap as rajk999 - you think no Christian will do good works or do their best to obey the commandments without the threat of hell hanging over their heads. You can’t comprehend someone doing the aforementioned from love and not fear.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.