17 Oct 12
Originally posted by robbie carrobieHe created the 'fulfillments' of "messianic prophecies" by working them into his writing decades after the death of the man he was promoting as the "Messiah" in the breakaway religion he was helping to set up.
you have FAILED to answer the question. How many did he create, you have asserted
that he created literature, how many of these did he create?
- Joined
- 16 Jan 07
- Moves
- 95105
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by robbie carrobiea 'young woman' doesnt give birth to the son of god every day but apparently this doesnt qualify as a special event to you. however the son of god riding a donkey does.
coming into Jerusalem in Jehovahs name and being extolled as King doesn't happen
every day, another stupendous FAIL! and as was pointed out to you before, the
messiah would need to fulfil all of the prophecies therefore your vain and ludicrous
attempts to take them in isolation is what, you guessed it, another EPIC FAIL!
hehe, you do make me chuckle.
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by FMFFAIL, if i write an account decades after a person has died that invalidates my text, that
They were written by people who lived and wrote decades after Jesus' death.
is what you are saying, another UTTERLY LUDICROUS ASSERTION, if that was the case
everything we know about Alexander the great is also moot, in fact, his account was
written not decades but some 300 years after his death! that is how stupid your
argument really is, that the proportions of its failure!
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by robbie carrobieWhat I have been saying is that the gospels were written by people who lived and wrote decades after Jesus' death and therefore they are not people who met Jesus in person.
FAIL, if i write an account decades after a person has died that invalidates my text, that
is what you are saying, another UTTERLY LUDICROUS ASSERTION!
17 Oct 12
1 edit
Originally posted by stellspalfiesorry you haven't explained anything, why you fail to understand that the messiah
a 'young woman' doesnt give birth to the son of god every day but apparently this doesnt qualify as a special event to you. however the son of god riding a donkey does.
hehe, you do make me chuckle.
must fulfil all of these and yet you insist in taking them in isolation is a testimony to
your inability to put the constituent parts together so as to form a whole.
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by FMFyou have provided not a shred of evidence, your opinions are therefore meaningless!
What I have been saying is that the gospels were written by people who lived and wrote decades after Jesus' death and therefore they are not people who met Jesus in person.
and as has been pointed out to you, decades after the event in terms of ancient history
is about as close as anyone is likely to get!
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by robbie carrobieThese authors did not meet Jesus. They believed Jesus was the Messiah. They created literature that made the case for the new religion they were setting up.
you have provided not a shred of evidence, your opinions are therefore meaningless!
and as has been pointed out to you, decades after the event in terms of ancient history
is about as close as anyone is likely to get!
17 Oct 12
1 edit
Originally posted by FMFThe history of Alexander is drawn from five ancient sources written 300 or more years
What I have been saying is that the gospels were written by people who lived and wrote decades after Jesus' death and therefore they are not people who met Jesus in person.
after he died. Not one eyewitness account of Alexander exists. Do you also assert that
these historical accounts were created, have no validity, are moot as you have stated
about the gospels, no why not?
- Joined
- 16 Jan 07
- Moves
- 95105
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by robbie carrobieim aware that the messiah is supposed to complete them all. if you cast your mind back to the start of my thread i was asking if christians thought jesus would complete the prophecies on his return. its perfectly sensible to look at each individual prophecy and ask if its been complete.
sorry you haven't explained anything, why you fail to understand that the messiah
must fulfil all of these and yet you insist in taking them in isolation is a testimony to
your inability to put the constituent parts together so as to form a whole.
now its your turn to explain why the birth needed to be magical but riding a donkey doesnt?
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by FMFmore drivel and unsubstantiated opinion, how many of the messianic prophecy's did
These authors did not meet Jesus. They believed Jesus was the Messiah. They created literature that made the case for the new religion they were setting up.
Matthew create, you have not said.
17 Oct 12
1 edit
Originally posted by stellspalfiethe birth was a sign, clearly it must be something extraordinary for it to be considered
im aware that the messiah is supposed to complete them all. if you cast your mind back to the start of my thread i was asking if christians thought jesus would complete the prophecies on his return. its perfectly sensible to look at each individual prophecy and ask if its been complete.
now its your turn to explain why the birth needed to be magical but riding a donkey doesnt?
a sign, yah think, a normal birth is not that extraordinary, is it, it happens everyday,
therefore it must have been some kind of special birth, mustn't it Sherlock?
- Joined
- 16 Jan 07
- Moves
- 95105
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by robbie carrobieand what was special about the donkey ride?
the birth was a sign, clearly it must be something extraordinary for it to be considered
a sign, yah think, a normal birth is not that extraordinary, is it, it happens everyday,
therefore it must have been some kind of special birth, mustn't it Sherlock?
17 Oct 12
Originally posted by robbie carrobieThe author referred to as Matthew, when he wrote his gospel, claimed however many "messianic prophecies" were fulfilled - 37 you say? - what does it matter? He could have claimed that there had been 400 references directly back to 400 "messianic prophecies" in the OT, or he could have claimed that there were 137 or 7 or 3. It doesn't really matter. He was creating literature needed to establish a religion centred on the notion that Jesus was the "Messiah".
more drivel and unsubstantiated opinion, how many of the messianic prophecy's did
Matthew create, you have not said.