New Testament

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
really Baldric?

Right on cue, out comes the name calling.

Originally posted by Proper Knob
Right on cue, out comes the name calling.

Its as lucid as anything you have proffered.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Its as lucid as anything you have proffered.

Come on, rise above the name calling please. This isn't the 'Clan Only' forum.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Its as lucid as anything you have proffered.

The things you appear to be telling yourself are often more intriguing than the things you appear to want to tell others.

Originally posted by Proper Knob
Come on, rise above the name calling please. This isn't the 'Clan Only' forum.

rise above what? you have claimed to know what Galveston meant by 'direct
communication', please tell the forum how you came to this conclusion and what it
means.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Its as lucid as anything you have proffered.

We never got to the bottom of whether JW literature is inspired like the Bible or not did we? Having had a few months to reflect on the matter, what's the answer?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
rise above what? you have claimed to know what Galveston meant by 'direct
communication', please tell the forum how you came to this conclusion and what it
means.

It's all spelled out in my previous posts.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
rise above what? you have claimed to know what Galveston meant by 'direct
communication', please tell the forum how you came to this conclusion and what it
means.

Proper Knob has been clear. You are clearly dodging.

Originally posted by Proper Knob
It's all spelled out in my previous posts.

no you have simply stated that you know, how do you know what the Gman meant by
'direct communication? As far as i can discern you have not provided anything by way
of substantiating evidence or your understanding is that the Holy spirit provides some
form of inspiration. Was direct communication even the Gmans words or were you
simply setting up your own assumptions in the hope that you could trick him into
acquiescing to something where his perceptions are different from yours based on his
understanding yet it appears to be the same thing as your perceptions? tell us what
your understanding of this direct communication is? God communicates aurally with
voice, provides writing on walls with materialized fingers, what? Do tell us.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
no you have simply stated that you know, how do you know what the Gman meant by
'direct communication? As far as i can discern you have not provided anything by way
of substantiating evidence or your understanding is that the Holy spirit provides some
form of inspiration. Was direct communication even the Gmans words or were you
simply set ...[text shortened]... es aurally with voice,
provides writing on walls with materialized fingers, what? Do tell us.

More dodging. Just answer Proper Knob's question.

Originally posted by Proper Knob
We never got to the bottom of whether JW literature is inspired like the Bible or not did we? Having had a few months to reflect on the matter, what's the answer?

I have repeated this a thousand times, our literature is not to be considered inspired as
the Bible is. As far as I am aware we have never claimed that our literature is inspired
as the Bible is inspired, if you have evidence to the contrary please provide it.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I have repeated this a thousand times, our literature is not to be considered inspired as the Bible is.

galveston75 has claimed, however, that your magazines are divinely inspired in the same way as the gospels were.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
no you have simply stated that you know, how do you know what the Gman meant by
'direct communication? As far as i can discern you have not provided anything by way
of substantiating evidence or your understanding is that the Holy spirit provides some
form of inspiration. Was direct communication even the Gmans words or were you
simply set ...[text shortened]... es aurally with voice,
provides writing on walls with materialized fingers, what? Do tell us.

I've spelled out my position over the course over a few posts all in this thread. Go and read it.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I have repeated this a thousand times, our literature is not to be considered inspired as
the Bible is. As far as I am aware we have never claimed that our literature is inspired
as the Bible is inspired, if you have evidence to the contrary please provide it.

Galveston has claimed that JW literature is inspired like the Bible.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
As far as I am aware we have never claimed that our literature is inspired
as the Bible is inspired, if you have evidence to the contrary please provide it.

galveston75 has claimed that your literature is inspired in the same way the Bible is inspired, as you well know.