Worlds problems....

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I dont think i have and i am not Galveston and he is not me, what is more, i have
provided clear scriptural references which illustrate the questions that are being asked,
why do you continually ignore them? It would appear to me that you are not really
interested in understanding why I have stated the things that I have and may have
some other motive, otherwise you would have made reference to them, wouldn't you.

The scriptures you have quoted do not address why you have been trying to pass off a clear difference of opinion between you and galveston75 as [1] not a difference of opinion and [2] it's somehow Proper Knob's fault and [3] that you have never researched this fundamental issue, do not know what the JW stance on it is, AND you're quoting scripture all of a sudden. It doesn't add up, robbie.

Originally posted by FMF
You seem to have changed your mind but don't want to concede that you have. This is the kind of thing that makes you seem so furtive.

whether i have changed my mind or not is irrelevant to the actual questions that you
have asked, you now have a clear Biblical reference for both scenarios.

Originally posted by FMF
The scriptures you have quoted do not address why you have been trying to pass off a clear difference of opinion between you and galveston75 as [1] not a difference of opinion and [2] it's somehow Proper Knob's fault and [3] that you have never researched this fundamental issue, do not know what the JW stance on it is, AND you're quoting scripture all of a sudden. It doesn't add up, robbie.

there is no difference in opinion.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
whether i have changed my mind or not is irrelevant to the actual questions that you
have asked, you now have a clear Biblical reference for both scenarios.

If you have changed your mind you should just say so because the way your responding to this makes you sound all over the place and it's as if 'not admitting error or change of mind' is the ONLY issue seriously in play for you.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
there is no difference in opinion.

Your statements were diametrically opposite and you tried to pass off his statements as being something other than what they clearly were. If you've changed your mind just say so.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
whether i have changed my mind or not is irrelevant to the actual questions that you
have asked, you now have a clear Biblical reference for both scenarios.

galveston75 claims that God withholds evidence from many Christians. is there any reason why we should not assume that God withholds evidence from JWs too?

Originally posted by FMF
galveston75 claims that God withholds evidence from many Christians. is there any reason why we should not assume that God withholds evidence from JWs too?

you may make reference to the Biblical passages that I have provided, which
demonstrate that God has withheld information not only from the angels, but Jesus
Christ himself.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
whether i have changed my mind or not is irrelevant to the actual questions that you
have asked, you now have a clear Biblical reference for both scenarios.

Do you accept you have changed your mind?

Originally posted by Proper Knob
Do you accept you have changed your mind?

Its possible but i couldn't possibly admit it. 😛

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Its possible but i couldn't possibly admit it. 😛

Why couldn't you admit it? What's the issue?

Originally posted by Proper Knob
Why couldn't you admit it? What's the issue?

I dont think its true, i was asked to give my comments on what i thought the Gman was
saying, i gave them as true as i could according to my ability and it appears to me that
I am being bullied into admitting something that's not quite true.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I dont think its true, i was asked to give my comments on what i thought the Gman was
saying, i gave them as true as i could according to my ability and it appears to me that
I am being bullied into admitting something that's not quite true.

You contradicted him, then said you hadn't, you claimed he hadn't said X when he had, then you claimed he had said X, then passed off the difference of opinion as "no difference of opinion". What is the personal issue or discomfort that you are wrestling with so publicly here?

Originally posted by FMF
galveston75 claims that God withholds evidence from many Christians. is there any reason why we should not assume that God withholds evidence from JWs too?

* BUMP for robbie *

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
whether i have changed my mind or not is irrelevant to the actual questions that you have asked,

Whether you have in fact changed your mind is totally relevant when you have been trying to pass it off as other people misunderstanding you or drawing incorrect inferences.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I dont think its true, i was asked to give my comments on what i thought the Gman was
saying, i gave them as true as i could according to my ability and it appears to me that
I am being bullied into admitting something that's not quite true.

Bullied??? LOL, have you been dipping into the well of tabloid journalism today? All i have done is pasted your own quotes back at you and asked you to comment.

Have you changed your mind or have you not?