Go back
Is Disfellowship Physically and Spiritually Necessary

Is Disfellowship Physically and Spiritually Necessary

Spirituality

galveston75
Texasman

San Antonio Texas

Joined
19 Jul 08
Moves
78873
Clock
18 Dec 14

WHY would they want to do this????????????????

Answer this please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

galveston75
Texasman

San Antonio Texas

Joined
19 Jul 08
Moves
78873
Clock
18 Dec 14

Originally posted by beauroberts
I was indeed greeted and welcomed to the site with open arms. Just to clarify I was not disfellowshipped at that time. I wasn't disfellowshipped until the beginning of April this year. You are just hearing about it now because I have been absent from the site and the forums until just last week for health reasons. Roughly seven months without any activit ...[text shortened]... s due to timeout due to inactivity. I appologize if this caused any clarity issues on your part.
I will respond with this. Only you, Jehovah and the elders involved know the issues. Jehovah is the reader of hearts and the one who judges all his servents. Jehovah as in the days of old used men of wisdom to guide all under his care. It is a heavy responsibility and one they take very serious. But just as in those days he still uses men of spiritual wisdom to guide his followers now. No differance as much as most here do not believe that is possible.
I hope in time your life will work out in a way you are happy with and that will hopefully include Jehovah and his organization.

I too was disfellowshipped many years ago and the correction was not easy to take and it hurt and it was embarrassing but only because I knew I did wrong. I made some bad decisions and in the end I knew it hurt Jehovah and brought reproach on his name and organization. I was reinstated and being disciplined was the best thing that has ever happened to me. It woke me up!!!!!

My suggestion to you is to be extremely careful as to the advise you are getting here. If you believe in Jehovah and that he loves you and wants you back, you will find no help here as none here even believe Jehovah is his name. How would they know him and his ways if they miss this simple fact?

Go back to the meetings..anywhere!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

divegeester
Support Your

Farmers

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120150
Clock
18 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
I will respond with this. Only you, Jehovah and the elders involved know the issues. Jehovah is the reader of hearts and the one who judges all his servents. Jehovah as in the days of old used men of wisdom to guide all under his care. It is a heavy responsibility and one they take very serious. But just as in those days he still uses men of spiritual wi ...[text shortened]... is ways if they miss this simple fact?

Go back to the meetings..anywhere!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
After ignoring and insulting the man for 8 pages, I think you have probably missed the opportunity to rescue the situation, no matter how many exclamation marks you deploy.

josephw
A fun title

Scoffer Mocker

Joined
27 Sep 06
Moves
9958
Clock
18 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by divegeester
As usual you chip in and yet say nothing at all.
Well geester, I was replying to Beau, and as usual you chime in where you weren't asked to.

I was rather thinking that Beau might be interested in why I thought so, but apparently he isn't. Otherwise I'm not interested in squabbling over the issue of church discipline, especially with those that don't know what the Bible has to say about it much less how it is applied.

galveston75
Texasman

San Antonio Texas

Joined
19 Jul 08
Moves
78873
Clock
18 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by divegeester
After ignoring and insulting the man for 8 pages, I think you have probably missed the opportunity to rescue the situation, no matter how many exclamation marks you deploy.
I didn't ask you for your opinion did I?

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
18 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
WHY would they want to do this????????????????

Answer this please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
For the reasons that have been laid out in multiple posts on this thread already.

galveston75
Texasman

San Antonio Texas

Joined
19 Jul 08
Moves
78873
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FMF
For the reasons that have been laid out in multiple posts on this thread already.
Sorry but must have missed that. Refresh me please....

With proof?

galveston75
Texasman

San Antonio Texas

Joined
19 Jul 08
Moves
78873
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by divegeester
After ignoring and insulting the man for 8 pages, I think you have probably missed the opportunity to rescue the situation, no matter how many exclamation marks you deploy.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Lol.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
Sorry but must have missed that. Refresh me please....

With proof?
What proof? I have offered my analysis just as you have. You calling into question beauroberts' integrity is not "proof" of anything.

galveston75
Texasman

San Antonio Texas

Joined
19 Jul 08
Moves
78873
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FMF
What proof? I have offered my analysis just as you have. You calling into question beauroberts' integrity is not "proof" of anything.
Where did I say his integraty was in question?

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
Where did I say his integraty was in question?
Well, despite reading long detailed accounts of what happened written by the person it happened to, you nevertheless claimed "I do not know the specifics as to what went on between him, his family or the elders. And "...I do not know any of the happenings or discussions that went on...". Such a summary dismissal of a fellow Christian's testimony is nothing if not calling his integrity into question.

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
If you believe in Jehovah and that he loves you and wants you back, you will find no help here as none here even believe Jehovah is his name.
Is it not the elders who decide whether someone who has been disfellowshipped can come back to the JW organisation (or, indeed, whether the JW organisation wants them back), and not "Jehovah"?

b
Father of Three

New Hampshire

Joined
25 Jan 14
Moves
8441
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
WHY would they want to do this????????????????

Answer this please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I am not denying I broke one of their rules. I am not saying they didn't have the right to disfellowship me. All I am simply saying is I received a blood transfusion after being told not to. I knew what I was doing. I was clinging to the precious gift which is life. A gift that was given to me by Jehovah God. I was also making sure I would be around for a long period of time to help bring my children up knowing who Jehovah is. I knew their beliefs in blood transfusions so them disfellowshipping me was of course their right. I am not disputing that...nor should you question this as I have been very honest and articulate about exactly how it happened.

That answers why they disfellowshipped me...pretty clear cut, cut and dry no other way to look at it. Thats why they did it...Why they would want to do it, I cannot speak for them or address their hearts or anything like that. I always thought I brought alot to the meetings. I partook in the kingdom ministry I was a borderline pioneer on top of ministry school and work and everything else. The truth is I loved going and I loved talking to the people and hearing the word. Albeit there were some things I did not fully buy into and therefore I probably should not have chosen to be baptised...entirely my fault and no fault of the organization. But It was my belief that by receiving the transfusion it would make me stronger giving me back my life allowing me to continue to edify and lift up Jehovah's good name. By receiving the transfusion it was my hope to be able to continue the very important field work.

I hope this answers your questions please feel free to ask more if it helps add clarity to the situation.

Beau

b
Father of Three

New Hampshire

Joined
25 Jan 14
Moves
8441
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
Sorry but must have missed that. Refresh me please....

With proof?
I do not require proof. I am a man of integrity, and will not have my good name questioned. I have done nothing and said nothing to cause you to question anything I have said or done.

I told you I was disfellowshipped. I told you the reason. I did not have to do that. Nor did I have explain how and why it happened. I having nothing against the brothers that were there when I was disfellowshipped. I even understand why they disfellowshipped me...all of this is crystal clear to me.

So in the interest of being a human being I think you owe me an apology.

divegeester
Support Your

Farmers

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120150
Clock
19 Dec 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by josephw
Well geester, I was replying to Beau, and as usual you chime in where you weren't asked to.

I was rather thinking that Beau might be interested in why I thought so, but apparently he isn't. Otherwise I'm not interested in squabbling over the issue of church discipline, especially with those that don't know what the Bible has to say about it much less how it is applied.
Another nothing post.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.